Sex addiction has yet to get a serious film treatment until
"Shame," the sophomore feature from filmmaker Steve McQueen.
Generally we feel inclined to put a comic spin on anything that taboo (see the
adaptation of Chuck Palahniuk's sex-addiction novel "Choke"), but
here we see how it ruins lives and relationships.
Like any addiction, main character Brandon (Michael
Fassbender) becomes preoccupied with sex, participating in everything from
prostitution to Internet pornography to relieving himself in the bathroom at
work. The film's first act is a long sample of how sex dominates most of
Brandon's thoughts as he goes through a typical week, a character study in
perversion but not one that demonizes his habit so much as displaying it for
what it is. We don't feel bad for Brandon nor do we despise him. Shame, aptly,
might be the most applicable emotion.
As with any character study, a lot hinges on Fassbender's
performance, and he delivers. Brandon isn't given a line of dialogue for what
feels like ages at the beginning, yet Fassbender perfectly (albeit somewhat
horrifyingly) telegraphs his internal thought process. McQueen is in perfect
sync, injecting us into Brandon's brain as best he can by subtly sexualizing a
lot of what Brandon sees. A sequence on the subway is entirely silent but
especially powerful as Brandon eyes a woman across the way.
Stretches of "Shame" will bore some viewers to
death, but it's a sacrifice McQueen makes to convey the solitude and loneliness
of a man with Brandon's condition. His lifestyle simply does not allow for
extended periods of human contact or long-term relationships. When he makes
efforts to do so in the film, it's painstaking for him. Much of the movie feels
superfluous (it could rank among the longest 100 minutes in film history), but
to some extent we cannot truly understand Brandon unless we are fully treated
to that isolation, to a complete lack of interest in anything but sex or
something that might lead to sex or sexual satisfaction.
After our first series of trials observing Brandon, McQueen
and co-writer Abi Morgan drop in Sissy (Carey Mulligan), Brandon's equally
troubled (in a whole other way) sister. Her on-screen introduction features her
completely nude and arguing with Brandon in the bathroom, which sets the table
for their relationship. Sissy is the opposite of Brandon, a jazz singer
completely dependent on human contact and emotional connection. Her intrusion
on Brandon's life understandably causes him to get angry and emotionally
volatile.
Brandon is not entirely averse to change, but he struggles
mightily with it. The third act is an experiment that achieves both positive
and negative results and digs into the question of whether or not one can
personally overcome something of this magnitude. Never, however, does the film
confront its themes or questions through dialogue. Only once does Sissy even
allude to Brandon's perversion, telling him he has no right to chastise anyone
else's sexual choices.
Fassbender and Mulligan ultimately anchor "Shame."
Without them, the film would be deemed powerfully told, but completely un-engaging.
Their raw performances and willingness to bare all physically and emotionally
create the hook that makes such a brooding character study work. McQueen
certainly deserves credit as well for working with them to create captivating
performances.
The subject matter of "Shame" is not an easy one
from a filmmaking perspective as well as a cultural one, but McQueen does an
honorable job with it. He recognizes which traditional storytelling practices
he must sacrifice in order to truly capture sex addiction tonally and
emotionally.
@David
ReplyDeleteThanks, man. You've inspired me to add two more posts this morning.
Cheers.